Very nice quality, nice packaging and came quick. They are a bit stiff but that is to be expected. Works great. No missed inputs!

I've used these to repair several controllers already. They are great replacements. They feel tighter than the originals but they function just the same.

This stick is a great quality replacement. Install was smooth as butter if you do it properly with the correct materials.
It's a bit stiffer than the original stick box, but that's to be expected.
It's also the proper height for aftermarket plastic thumb sticks. I got my plastic piece from retromodding, and found it was too low on the original box. I got careless and melted my oem plastic piece with my soldering iron. Luckily i had the spare.

The plastic parts are also quite tough to get onto the stick, but it's nothing outrageous. Overall it's a great part in my eyes.