I bought this mostly to replace a stick in an original wavebird with a beat up thumb cap. I'm very happy with the quality of that stick. The cap feels right and they made sure to include the notch on the base. Only issues, it is a tight fit and is a bit too short. This can be overcome by pulling the stick up a little bit after installing it. Because it's a tight fit it will stay at the height you pick.
The c-stick is not as well made. It's completely plastic and is the wrong color. At this price I'm happy to just get the thumbstick and have a spare c-stick if I absolutely need it.
