Gameboy Advance Tactile Conversion PCB - HHL

Not only does it make all the buttons clicky but they are no longer mushy. I tried some 3D printed addons and even a slip of paper to get rid of the button mushyness, but those were all terrible 'fixes' for the mushy buttons. This mod truly makes the GBA feel like its supposed to and should be standard in any modded console!

I did this mod with the HHL RGB lighting as well as a bunch of other on board mods. I had to set the tactile conversion kit on the very base layer then relayer all the other mods on top. I did have some issues first go around where my A button wasn't working or my B button. I noticed i didn't solder the square pin in the top right corner, so I did that and the issue was resolved. Not sure if thats what caused the issue or if i set the PCB down poorly. Overall just double check you are well lined up and flush to the board!

Still a bit on the fence about this mod. I wanted to give it some time before passing judgment. I tried several membranes and none really felt all that great I ended up using a well-worn funny playing membrane. Everything just feels really tight when it's all buttoned up, a custom-made membrane would probably feel much better. As it is it's clicky and not too hard to press.

I had to make a shim for the center to stop the D-pad from mashing all the buttons at once. It worked pretty well. I ultimately discarded the start/select buttons (had issues with existing mods) and the A & B buttons due to how the membrane felt. I would feel the flexing of the membrane right before the button press making it feel like a double press.

If there was a custom membrane(s) for this so things wouldn't have to be screwed down so tightly, an make the press feel lighter, it would elevate this mod a lot. There's just a lot of membrane crammed into a tighter space now.

Very solid and easy to install. I installed it in a GBA with an IPS screen mod and it fits perfectly. Sounds and feels great. They're obviously not as good as the original SP buttons but still marginally better feeling (in my opinion) than the original GBA dpad.

I’ve tried several clicks shoulder buttons, and these have by far been the easiest to install and the most complimented among my customers. 10/10

They were cool, but after I installed them, I wasn't able to comfortably close it back up without it feeling too crammed. maybe if there were a thinner membrane that went with it... This was also my first time doing this kind of thing, so it also could've been my fault.

I don't see the point. I installed these on mine, and if you have good membranes to start then these do not help. They create a "two stage" click feel. Your first press of the button is the membrane bottoming, then you have to press through to get the additional tactile click. Honestly, not a great experience, I wouldn't do it again.
One thing it can do is that you can somewhat "preload" your button press if you are trying to be precise. But if you play any kind of button mashing game, I think this is a terrible mod because if feels like you are pressing through twice.